These 4 Pairs of Shoes Are Some of the Most Comfortable We’ve Tested—And They’re Perfect for Spring

Senior Shopping Editor

There's a reason our parents had us walk around the store with a new pair of shoes before buying them: Along with making sure they fit, they also wanted to confirm that we were comfortable. Nowadays, it's far more convenient to skip the mall visit and opt for home delivery instead—but with no virtual try-on, the risk of blisters, chafing, and poor support is always a risk.

At Real Simple, we've tested more than 70 pairs of shoes, from slides and flats to heels and sneakers. So whether you're going out to walk the dog, making the commute to work, or tearing up the dance floor, we've got you covered with these stylish and supremely comfortable kicks.

1. We thought the Reef Cushion Vera Cruz Slides were exceptionally comfortable from the first wear. The vegan leather feels soft and pliable, and the sole contoured to our foot for custom arch support. The hibiscus-stamped insole prevented us from slipping, and the outsole had excellent traction for post-rain strolls and lake days. These gorgeous sandals marry fashion and function—a reliable pair for the beach, running errands, or a nice summer dinner.

2. Knit from recycled plastic bottles, you might think Rothy's The Square Mary Jane sounds uncomfortable, but this lightweight shoe comfortably powered through our daily 10,000 step goal. The durable, flexible sole supported our feet on pavement, pebbles, and cobblestone, and were suitable for both hot and cold weather. There was no break-in period, and they even accommodated swollen ankles during our tester's pregnancy.

3. Heels are notorious for being uncomfortable, but the Dream Pairs Pump Sandal is a different story. We felt immediate comfort with no break-in period, and the chunky 2-inch heel and ankle strap provided solid support and a secure fit. Here's the kicker: This pair costs under $40.

4. A good pair of white sneakers should be in everybody's warm weather rotation, and we practically live in the Cariuma Salvas. Not only do they go with every outfit, but they also offer cloud-like comfort through miles of walking. They are made from ethically-sourced leather and cushy foam for awesome shock absorption. Don't just take it from us: These sustainable sneakers are so popular that they often sell out.

Products I'm Loving Right Now